| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 1 | Ike | Scottie Scheffler | ||
| 2 | Gabes | Xander Schauffele | ||
| 3 | Jack | Collin Morikawa | ||
| 4 | Mags | Ludvig Åberg | ||
| 5 | Sobo | Rory McIlroy | ||
| 6 | Charlie | Wyndham Clark | posted by Sobo | |
| 7 | Andy | Sahith Theegala | ||
| 8 | Al | Hideki Matsuyama | Posted by Gabes. | |
| 9 | Hans | Sungjae Im | ||
| 10 | Fox | Sam Burns |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 11 | Fox | Justin Thomas | My bar buddy! | |
| 12 | Hans | Akshay Bhatia | ||
| 13 | Al | Patrick Cantlay | Posted by Gabes | |
| 14 | Andy | Tony Finau | ||
| 15 | Charlie | Robert MacIntyre | Coming right back with him! | |
| 16 | Sobo | Davis Thompson | ||
| 17 | Mags | Maverick McNealy | ||
| 18 | Jack | Billy Horschel | My Favorite Gator! | |
| 19 | Gabes | Tommy Fleetwood | ||
| 20 | Ike | Viktor Hovland |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 21 | Ike | Cameron Young | ||
| 22 | Gabes | Tom Kim | ||
| 23 | Jack | Max Greyserman | ||
| 24 | Mags | Shane Lowry | ||
| 25 | Sobo | Taylor Pendrith | ||
| 26 | Charlie | Austin Eckroat | My Man | |
| 27 | Andy | Corey Conners | ||
| 28 | Al | Byeong Hun An | Chuck knows how much I like those Asian golfers. Japan and round one, South Korea and round 3 | |
| 29 | Hans | Russell Henley | ||
| 30 | Fox | Adam Scott | entered by Mags |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 31 | Fox | Ben Griffin | entered by Mags | |
| 32 | Hans | Aaron Rai | ||
| 33 | Al | Will Zalatoris | ||
| 34 | Andy | Tom Hoge | ||
| 35 | Charlie | Max Homa | Comeback Golfer of the Year 2025 | |
| 36 | Sobo | Jordan Spieth | The REAL Comeback Golfer of the Year in 2025! | |
| 37 | Mags | J.T. Poston | ||
| 38 | Jack | Brian Harman | ||
| 39 | Gabes | Matt Fitzpatrick | ||
| 40 | Ike | Cam Davis |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 41 | Ike | Denny McCarthy | ||
| 42 | Gabes | Sepp Straka | ||
| 43 | Jack | Keegan Bradley | ||
| 44 | Mags | Jason Day | Hopefully my lucky Day! | |
| 45 | Sobo | Si Woo Kim | hopefullybetter than my last Kim! | |
| 46 | Charlie | Eric Cole | ||
| 47 | Andy | Nick Dunlap | ||
| 48 | Al | Matthieu Pavon | Pick posted by Hans | |
| 49 | Hans | Chris Kirk | ||
| 50 | Fox | Christiaan Bezuidenhout | ah choo! |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 51 | Fox | Mackenzie Hughes | ||
| 52 | Hans | Thomas Detry | ||
| 53 | Al | Stephan Jaeger | ||
| 54 | Andy | Kurt Kitayama | Posted by Gabes | |
| 55 | Charlie | Min Woo Lee | This one’s for you Al!! | |
| 56 | Sobo | Daniel Berger | Guys- my apologies for the hold up. Our flight from Dallas to Chicago was diverted to Indy due to weather and we were stuck on the ground with no power. | |
| 57 | Mags | Kevin Yu | ||
| 58 | Jack | Patrick Rodgers | ||
| 59 | Gabes | Alex Noren | ||
| 60 | Ike | Matt McCarty | Posted by Gabes |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 61 | Ike | Harris English | Posted by Gabes | |
| 62 | Gabes | Nico Echavarria | ||
| 63 | Jack | Mark Hubbard | ||
| 64 | Mags | Rasmus Højgaard | ||
| 65 | Sobo | Erik van Rooyen | Posted by Gabes. | |
| 66 | Charlie | Nick Taylor | ||
| 67 | Andy | Michael Thorbjornsen | Posted by Gabes. | |
| 68 | Al | Keith Mitchell | I have owned this underachieving golfer for so many years. It would kill me not to own him when he finally breaks through. So one more time… | |
| 69 | Hans | Seamus Power | ||
| 70 | Fox | Jon Rahm | I think it is time |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 71 | Fox | Bryson DeChambeau | ||
| 72 | Hans | Brooks Koepka | ||
| 73 | Al | Taylor Moore | I was thinking of selecting a LIV golfer here. Yet all 3 that I would consider were snapped up immediately before me. Okay, I will just sit out the major side pools | |
| 74 | Andy | Cameron Smith | Posted by Gabes. | |
| 75 | Charlie | Lee Hodges | ||
| 76 | Sobo | Adam Hadwin | ||
| 77 | Mags | Harry Hall | ||
| 78 | Jack | Jake Knapp | ||
| 79 | Gabes | Beau Hossler | ||
| 80 | Ike | Justin Rose |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 81 | Ike | Thristen Lawrence | ||
| 82 | Gabes | Tyrrell Hatton | ||
| 83 | Jack | Doug Ghim | ||
| 84 | Mags | Patrick Fishburn | ||
| 85 | Sobo | Andrew Novak | ||
| 86 | Charlie | Davis Riley | ||
| 87 | Andy | Nicolai Højgaard | ||
| 88 | Al | Aldrich Potgieter | ||
| 89 | Hans | Emiliano Grillo | ||
| 90 | Fox | Sam Stevens |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 91 | Fox | Mac Meissner | ||
| 92 | Hans | Brendon Todd | ||
| 93 | Al | Ryo Hisatsune | Posted by Mags with Al’s directions | |
| 94 | Andy | Lucas Glover | ||
| 95 | Charlie | Matt Wallace | ||
| 96 | Sobo | Victor Perez | Posted by Gabes. | |
| 97 | Mags | Max McGreevy | ||
| 98 | Jack | Luke List | ||
| 99 | Gabes | Rico Hoey | ||
| 100 | Ike | Justin Lower |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 101 | Ike | Luke Clanton | ||
| 102 | Gabes | Rickie Fowler | ||
| 103 | Jack | Jhonattan Vegas | ||
| 104 | Mags | Chan Kim | ||
| 105 | Sobo | Frankie Capan III | Time to take a flyer! | |
| 106 | Charlie | Chandler Phillips | ||
| 107 | Andy | Andrew Putnam | ||
| 108 | Al | J.J. Spaun | I analyzed extensively and decided upon my golfer: Chandler Phillips. I could not find him on either drop down.then I saw that Chuck grabbed him 2 slots earlier. Bastard! | |
| 109 | Hans | Jacob Bridgeman | ||
| 110 | Fox | Michael Kim | Posted by Gabes. |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 111 | Fox | Jesper Svensson | Posted by Gabes. | |
| 112 | Hans | Adam Schenk | ||
| 113 | Al | Matti Schmid | ||
| 114 | Andy | Joe Highsmith | ||
| 115 | Charlie | Vince Whaley | ||
| 116 | Sobo | Steven Fisk | ||
| 117 | Mags | Ryan Gerard | ||
| 118 | Jack | Charley Hoffman | ||
| 119 | Gabes | Takumi Kanaya | ||
| 120 | Ike | Adam Svensson |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 121 | Ike | Carson Young | ||
| 122 | Gabes | Ben Silverman | ||
| 123 | Jack | Matt Kuchar | ||
| 124 | Mags | Pierceson Coody | ||
| 125 | Sobo | Bud Cauley | ||
| 126 | Charlie | Henrik Norlander | ||
| 127 | Andy | Patton Kizzire | ||
| 128 | Al | Chris Gotterup | DB alumnus from last year. He won a stupid inconsequential tournament in Myrtle Beach with the big boys playing elsewhere. But it does give him a ticket to Maui | |
| 129 | Hans | Greyson Sigg | ||
| 130 | Fox | Tom McKibbin | Nollaig Shona Duit, see you on the 26th! |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 131 | Fox | C.T. Pan | ||
| 132 | Hans | Ryan Fox | ||
| 133 | Al | Sami Valimaki | ||
| 134 | Andy | Adrian Meronk | Posted by Gabes. | |
| 135 | Charlie | Alex Smalley | ||
| 136 | Sobo | K.H. Lee | ||
| 137 | Mags | Quade Cummins | ||
| 138 | Jack | Peter Malnati | ||
| 139 | Gabes | Jackson Suber | ||
| 140 | Ike | Matteo Manassero |