| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 1 | Hans | Jordan Spieth | let the fun begin! | |
| 2 | Mags | Jason Day | ||
| 3 | Andy | Rory McIlroy | ||
| 4 | Jack | Bubba Watson | ||
| 5 | Willo | Rickie Fowler | Posted by Gabes | |
| 6 | Fox | Dustin Johnson | happy with this I guess | |
| 7 | Gabes | Hideki Matsuyama | Like his upside more than any others at pick 7! | |
| 8 | Al | Justin Rose | posted by Fox .. Al sent me provisionals but just now noticed them | |
| 9 | Ike | Brooks Koepka | ||
| 10 | Sobo | Matt Kuchar |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 11 | Sobo | Patrick Reed | ||
| 12 | Ike | Henrik Stenson | ||
| 13 | Al | Zach Johnson | posted by fox .. nice job with the provisionals Albert | |
| 14 | Gabes | Justin Thomas | ||
| 15 | Fox | Paul Casey | ok .. everyone be careful to only make pick when it is your turn .. reload web page possibly before making pick | |
| 16 | Willo | J.B. Holmes | I'm a freaking idiot!! | |
| 17 | Jack | Jimmy Walker | ||
| 18 | Andy | Kevin Na | Posted by Gabes. Fox is a Homo! Posted by Gabes. | |
| 19 | Mags | Kevin Kisner | This might be my pick | |
| 20 | Hans | Brandt Snedeker |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 21 | Hans | Robert Streb | Staying with golfers whose last name starts with S | |
| 22 | Mags | Danny Lee | ||
| 23 | Andy | Jason Bohn | Posted by Gabes | |
| 24 | Jack | Jim Furyk | One for the old guys. | |
| 25 | Willo | Bill Haas | Hopefully this works. | |
| 26 | Fox | Adam Scott | ||
| 27 | Gabes | Sergio Garcia | ||
| 28 | Al | Phil Mickelson | ||
| 29 | Ike | Louis Oosthuizen | ||
| 30 | Sobo | Patrick Rodgers |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 31 | Sobo | Daniel Berger | ||
| 32 | Ike | Chris Kirk | ||
| 33 | Al | Tony Finau | Posted by Gabes | |
| 34 | Gabes | Branden Grace | ||
| 35 | Fox | Russell Henley | ||
| 36 | Willo | Billy Horschel | ||
| 37 | Jack | Sangmoon Bae | ||
| 38 | Andy | Charl Schwartzel | Posted by Mags | |
| 39 | Mags | Russell Knox | ||
| 40 | Hans | Scott Piercy |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 41 | Hans | David Lingmerth | ||
| 42 | Mags | Graeme McDowell | ||
| 43 | Andy | John Senden | Send in Senden | |
| 44 | Jack | Harris English | ||
| 45 | Willo | Keegan Bradley | Awful last year but reborn in 2016? | |
| 46 | Fox | Webb Simpson | ||
| 47 | Gabes | Emiliano Grillo | ||
| 48 | Al | S. Kaufman | Posted by Mags | |
| 49 | Ike | Cameron Smith | ||
| 50 | Sobo | Hunter Mahan | Welcome back Hunter! |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 51 | Sobo | Patton Kizzire | ||
| 52 | Ike | Ryan Moore | ||
| 53 | Al | Ben Martin | ||
| 54 | Gabes | Marc Leishman | ||
| 55 | Fox | Jason Dufner | ||
| 56 | Willo | Charley Hoffman | ||
| 57 | Jack | Daniel Summerhays | ||
| 58 | Andy | Gary Woodland | Posted by Gabes | |
| 59 | Mags | Ryan Palmer | ||
| 60 | Hans | Matt Jones |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 61 | Hans | Martin Kaymer | looking for a repeat of 2014 when he won twice including the US Open | |
| 62 | Mags | Cameron Tringale | ||
| 63 | Andy | Ian Poulter | Posted by Gabes | |
| 64 | Jack | Brendon de Jonge | Had a nice dinner party tonight. Most of you cretins would not understand Especially Douchebag SPARTY & Numbnuts IKEY | |
| 65 | Willo | Brendan Steele | ||
| 66 | Fox | James Hahn | ||
| 67 | Gabes | Kevin Chappell | GOOD MORNING CYBERZAHM! | |
| 68 | Al | Steven Bowditch | Perhaps a flash in the pan last year... but maybe a late bloomer just finding his way. | |
| 69 | Ike | Brendon Todd | ||
| 70 | Sobo | Shawn Stefani |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 71 | Sobo | Will Wilcox | ||
| 72 | Ike | Graham DeLaet | ||
| 73 | Al | Morgan Hoffmann | Wilcox was my #1 choice, snaked by Sobo. But Hoffman shares similar profile... might be an interesting sidebet | |
| 74 | Gabes | Brian Harman | ||
| 75 | Fox | Charles Howell III | ||
| 76 | Willo | William McGirt | ||
| 77 | Jack | Nick Watney | ||
| 78 | Andy | Freddie Jacobson | Is he still alive? | |
| 79 | Mags | David Hearn | ||
| 80 | Hans | Alex Cejka |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 81 | Hans | Troy Merritt | ||
| 82 | Mags | Boo Weekley | I get to boo weekly once again | |
| 83 | Andy | Lee Westwood | ||
| 84 | Jack | Zac Blair | Going with the youngster. He will not be drafted into military service. Fuck you IKEY! | |
| 85 | Willo | Luke Donald | ||
| 86 | Fox | Kevin Streelman | Snaked by Willo. | |
| 87 | Gabes | Peter Malnati | ||
| 88 | Al | Martin Laird | ||
| 89 | Ike | Francesco Molinari | ||
| 90 | Sobo | Anirban Lahiri |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 91 | Sobo | Sean OHair | ||
| 92 | Ike | Chris Stroud | ||
| 93 | Al | Pat Perez | ||
| 94 | Gabes | Roberto Castro | ||
| 95 | Fox | Rory Sabbatini | ||
| 96 | Willo | Adam Hadwin | A real up and coming stud, question is when? | |
| 97 | Jack | Fabian Gomez | ||
| 98 | Andy | Jonas Blixt | ||
| 99 | Mags | Jerry Kelly | ||
| 100 | Hans | George McNeill |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 101 | Hans | Dawte Van Der Walt | off the Web.com tour. hopefully he is a big time player... | |
| 102 | Mags | Shane Lowry | ||
| 103 | Andy | Tiger Woods | Hey, it could happen .... | |
| 104 | Jack | Colt Knost | ||
| 105 | Willo | Chesson Hadley | Brilliance in the 11th round... | |
| 106 | Fox | Chad Campbell | ||
| 107 | Gabes | Hudson Swafford | ||
| 108 | Al | Jason Kokrak | Getting to the bottom of the barrel | |
| 109 | Ike | Seung-Yul Noh | ||
| 110 | Sobo | J.J. Henry | Ike- you snaked me in the first round and in the last! |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 111 | Sobo | John Huh | huh? | |
| 112 | Ike | Danny Willett | Jenga! Fini!! | |
| 113 | Al | Bryce Molder | Terrible weekend player but plays often, makes cuts | |
| 114 | Gabes | Spencer Levin | ||
| 115 | Fox | David Toms | ||
| 116 | Willo | Jamie Lovemark | And a merry Christmas to all.... | |
| 117 | Jack | Padraig Harrington | Ending with an Irishman!! Good draft by all | |
| 118 | Andy | Kevin Stadler | Posted by Mags | |
| 119 | Mags | Jim Herman | ||
| 120 | Hans | Scott Brown |