| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 1 | Mags | Steve Stricker | Hopefully last year was not a fluke. | |
| 2 | Andy | Tiger Woods | Damned if do, Damned if don't. | |
| 3 | Jack | Zach Johnson | At 33, in his prime and hopefully he builds upon last year. | |
| 4 | Hans | Phil Mickelson | 1st time I've had Lefty. should be fun, I hope. | |
| 5 | Sobo | Sean O'Hair | Fox- Couldn't find him in the pull down... | |
| 6 | Gabes | Jim Furyk | ||
| 7 | Fox | Lucas Glover | Posted by mags | |
| 8 | Al | Geoff Ogilvy | A legacy selection |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 9 | Al | Camilo Villegas | Hans... who is a lot smarter than me.... drafted him in first round in 2009. I am betting on a bounce back season | |
| 10 | Fox | Kevin Na | ... | |
| 11 | Gabes | Rory McIlroy | ||
| 12 | Sobo | Hunter Mahan | good morning to all! | |
| 13 | Hans | Padraig Harrington | Another 1st timer on the Ace Holes | |
| 14 | Jack | David Toms | sobo for jack | |
| 15 | Andy | Retief Goosen | A first time hooker. | |
| 16 | Mags | Kenny Perry | Spells Money |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 17 | Mags | Paul Casey | Is Money | |
| 18 | Andy | Anthony Kim | Let me down last year. Don't want to miss his upside when he starts to bring it all together. | |
| 19 | Jack | Stewart Cink | Colts are losing, Peyton is out, hope jack is having a better time with this pick. | |
| 20 | Hans | Y.E. Yang | need to pick him ahead of Fox. Hopefully he'll repeat a 2 win season, including a major | |
| 21 | Sobo | Sergio Garcia | Posted by Gabes | |
| 22 | Gabes | Henrik Stenson | ||
| 23 | Fox | Ernie Els | Can't believe Gabes didn't take when he is poised to have the greatest year of his already amazing career! | |
| 24 | Al | Nick Watney | Last man picked last year. Then dropped and grabbed by the lucky phucker Fox |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 25 | Al | Rory Sabbatini | A legacy delection. I know someone will (happy to see Dustin coming back around | |
| 26 | Fox | Vijay Singh | it is called gambling | |
| 27 | Gabes | Luke Donald | ||
| 28 | Sobo | Dustin Johnson | Thanks Al. A little wager on Dustin vs. the Little Angry One? | |
| 29 | Hans | Lee Westwood | Doesnt play the PGA Tour much, but when he does, he's very good | |
| 30 | Jack | Ian Poulter | Only played 17 times but plays in majors and had 12 top 25s. | |
| 31 | Andy | Ryan Moore | I think I read somewhere where he was supposed to be good. Actually, I'm not very good at this rotogolf thing, so WTF. | |
| 32 | Mags | Tim Clark |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 33 | Mags | Steve Marino | ||
| 34 | Andy | Adam Scott | Yes, I believe. BTW: It's a girl! 11 lb. 2 oz.,23 1/4 inches. She rode her bike home from the hospital! | |
| 35 | Jack | Matt Kuchar | Going young this year (32) | |
| 36 | Hans | Brian Gay | coming out of the closet! | |
| 37 | Sobo | Jerry Kelly | Sorry Gabes.... | |
| 38 | Gabes | Mike Weir | ||
| 39 | Fox | Stephen Ames | decided i liked ames, gay, and weir in that order a few hours ago .. got my top guy .. but do wish I had weir on the comeback round | |
| 40 | Al | John Senden | going down under |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 41 | Al | Robert Allenby | one more time down under | |
| 42 | Fox | Chad Campbell | A Fox once again | |
| 43 | Gabes | Michalel Sim | sobo for gabes | |
| 44 | Sobo | Justin Leonard | ||
| 45 | Hans | Brandt Snedeker | maybe he'll show up this year | |
| 46 | Jack | Angel Cabrera | First time Smoothie - like the perrformance in majors. Let's keep this thing moving! | |
| 47 | Andy | John Rollins | Getting tough now. Now I start taking guys like, John Rollins. | |
| 48 | Mags | Scott Verplank |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 49 | Mags | Charley Hoffman | ||
| 50 | Andy | Heath Slocum | I think he's still an active golfer. | |
| 51 | Jack | Jason Dufner | Go Badgers | |
| 52 | Hans | Marc Leishman | good morning | |
| 53 | Sobo | Pat Perez | ||
| 54 | Gabes | Mark Wilson | ||
| 55 | Fox | Bo Van Pelt | statistically significant increase in his number of 1-putt greens towards the end of 2009 indicates increasing accuracy and bodes well for a great year | |
| 56 | Al | Jonathan Byrd | Fox snaked me on Van Pelt, but always liked Mr. Byrd, a Dimpled Ball yet again. |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 57 | Al | Webb Simpson | For the same reasons Hans took Leishman, I am taking Simpson. Solid rookie season, young, lots of upside. A Dimpled Ball once again | |
| 58 | Fox | K.J. Choi | My team blows anyway. | |
| 59 | Gabes | Ben Crane | ||
| 60 | Sobo | Boo Weekley | Time for a Redneck Rebound from a first time Pinseeker! | |
| 61 | Hans | Martin Laird | needed another winner from 09 | |
| 62 | Jack | Tim Petrovic | Posted by Gabes | |
| 63 | Andy | Ryuji Imada | Because my team blows more than Fox's team. | |
| 64 | Mags | Bill Haas |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 65 | Mags | Brian Davis | ||
| 66 | Andy | Rocco Mediate | I think he won something once. | |
| 67 | Jack | Charles Howell III | The Turd has been a Smoothie before and will be one again!!! | |
| 68 | Hans | Justin Rose | ||
| 69 | Sobo | Rickie Fowler | Posted by Gabes | |
| 70 | Gabes | Davis Love III | ||
| 71 | Fox | Jason Day | All indicators are that he might play golf this coming year. | |
| 72 | Al | Troy Matteson | Still young, broke thru last year, tees it up often, and one of the last entrants into limited field event to start the year |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 73 | Al | D.J. Trahan | Here's hoping this young talent decides that playing like Tiger should be a pre-req to partying and screwing around like Tiger | |
| 74 | Fox | Kevin Sutherland | Steady player .. boring, but steady | |
| 75 | Gabes | Nathan Green | ||
| 76 | Sobo | Aaron Baddeley | Another bounceback? Hope so. | |
| 77 | Hans | Bryce Molder | Good Morning | |
| 78 | Jack | Bubba Watson | If you are from Indiana, you have to ahve a Bubba on your team | |
| 79 | Andy | Trevor Immelman | He's better than Tommy Armour | |
| 80 | Mags | John Mallinger | I'm recuperating from trek up-down-across the Garden State. Stuck in the Pine Barrens somewhere. I forgot what butthead drivers the Jerseyeans are. Speaking of butthead drivers, here's my next rotogolf pick. Oh, and Al, kiss my ass. |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 81 | Mags | George McNeill | Another lousy driver, but then again, so is Tiger. | |
| 82 | Andy | Briny Baird | Because my team really blows. Who the hell is Rocco Mediate? | |
| 83 | Jack | James Nitties | Happy New Year Everybody! | |
| 84 | Hans | Mathew Goggin | Just spoke with Hans and posted for him. | |
| 85 | Sobo | J.J. Henry | Hans- You got me again with Goggins, but I still love you, man. Happy New Year to all! | |
| 86 | Gabes | Jeff Klauk | ||
| 87 | Fox | Charlie Wi | Wheeeeeeee! Happy New Year!!!!!!! | |
| 88 | Al | Carl Pettersson | Posted by Gabes |
| Pick | Owner | Player | Pithy Comment | |
| 89 | Al | Jeff Overton | Posted by Gabes | |
| 90 | Fox | Ross Fisher | Breaking a rule I have found helpful during most drafts and choosing a player I never heard of ... cheers! | |
| 91 | Gabes | Woody Austin | It's New Year's Eve. Time for a Woody! Happy New Year to All! Let's finish this thing tomorrow, or you will be hearing from Commissioner Asshole! | |
| 92 | Sobo | Stuart Appleby | Welcome to 2010! | |
| 93 | Hans | John Merrick | happy new year - let the games begin! good luck to all. Tiger, take your time sorting out personal issues. | |
| 94 | Jack | J.B. Holmes | Unlike me, at least he can drive it | |
| 95 | Andy | John Daly | Somehow seems fitting this morning. You're up, Cinderalla | |
| 96 | Mags | Matt Jones | Oh well, that's that. |